‘Too much democracy’ a stumbling block for land bill in India, feel Chinese

NEW DELHI: Even as members of the Opposition and the ruling Bharatiya Janata Party slug it out over the Land Acquisition Bill in Parliament, the Chinese believe that is precisely the problem with India – “too much democracy.”

During a visit to Xi’an in Shanxi province in China last week, ET learnt how the country developed its Land Use Rights System and overcame issues such as acquisition of property, especially from farmers, to continue with its rapid growth. “There are deadlines given to the farmers. If they do not give their consent by then, the State is authorised to acquire that land,” Wang Menghao, Project Manager of Foreign Investment Promotion Board (FIPB) of Xi’an Hi-tech Industries Development Zone (XHTZ) told ET.

According to him, India faces this problem and is unable to get the law on land acquisition in place because it follows the democratic system. This was also the general view of other officials and experts in China.

“It is natural that people will not like to part with their land happily. In China, the land belongs to the state and people do not have an option beyond a point. The state can take back its land at any time. In India, it gets complicated because of the system and processes,” Menghao said.

Displaced farmers are offered alternative plots in lieu of the land acquired by the government. “The compensation could also include money and jobs,” he added. Spread over 307 square km, the XHTZ was established in 1991 as one of the earliest Chinese science parks at the national level.

Regarded as one of the most successful of the 114 national high-tech zones in the country, an economic zone within this was approved in 2009. This is where China wants to develop a software city like Bengaluru. XHTZ officials said there were bound to be some protests when people are asked to move out of an area where they have lived for years.

“When land has to be acquired by the government, an information sign is generally put up in the village as an announcement.

Villagers are then required to complain within a week if they have a problem. If they do not come forward to complain, it is assumed they have agreed to the land transfer,” explained an official.

As in India, farmers in China don’t deal with investors directly. The land is first acquired by the state for “public interest” and then sold to the developer or investor. There was no social impact assessment, either. Manghao said the state takes care of displaced farmers and communities. He said many of them are offered jobs in the industries that came up on the land.

“The government offers education and training to the people so that they can either work there or get a job somewhere else and be self-sufficient,” he explained.

In addition, there are provisions for skilling and micro-finance to encourage displaced people to set up their own small-scale industrial units, he said.

Article source: http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/politics-and-nation/too-much-democracy-a-stumbling-block-for-land-bill-in-india-feel-chinese/articleshow/47007164.cms

Posted in Plot in India |

Telangana MLAs turn ‘progressive farmers’ to attend agriculture exhibition in …

Telangana government has decided to send an eight-member team, including four MLAs of the ruling TRS with a tag of “progressive farmers”, to attend an agriculture exhibition and field trips in Israel. The decision has kicked up a row with … Continue reading

Posted in Plot in India |

Frontline’s ‘American Terrorist’: How Do You Stop Home-Grown Terrorism?

A remarkable documentary, Frontline’s American Terrorist tells the tale of David Coleman Headley, a U.S.-born citizen who was a key member of the terrorist cell that killed more than 150 people in the 2008 attacks in Mumbai, India. American Terrorist … Continue reading

Posted in Plot in India |

Property worth lakhs destroyed in fire

‘); $(“#FaceBookLikeButton”).show(); popupWin.document.close(); } Property worth lakhs of rupees was gutted after a fire broke out in a building at New Osmangunj Market in Begum Bazar on Tuesday morning triggering panic among the local residents and shopkeepers. Fortunately, no casualties … Continue reading

Posted in Property news |

Inside the 24 April edition

As I was commuting home Monday night on London Underground’s Northern Line, I noticed a woman seated opposite me pull an edition of Guardian Weekly from her bag and begin reading. It was satisfying to encounter someone delving deeply into … Continue reading

Posted in Plot in India |

Hong Kong and Macau citizens need permission to buy property in India

April 20th, 2015 Adrian Bishop Asia, News 0 comments Citizens of two administrative areas of China now have to obtain permission from the Reserve Bank of India before being able to buy or transfer property in India. The Reserve Bank … Continue reading

Posted in Property news |

NMC hikes property tax by two times

NAGPUR: Citizens will have to pay two times more property tax for residential properties and three times more for commercial properties from the current fiscal. The Nagpur Municipal Corporation (NMC) general body approved implementation of the new property tax system … Continue reading

Posted in Property news |

BMC struggles to handle 25000 DP objections

MUMBAI: Inadequately equipped civic officials are struggling to handle 25,000 suggestions/objections they have received till Monday on the draft Development Plan (DP) 2034. Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC) officials are maintaining the applications’ basic details in their office register and on … Continue reading

Posted in Plot in India |

Opposing grants to war veteran costs state Rs 50000

MUMBAI: The Bombay high court on Monday directed the state government to pay Rs 50,000 as costs to a 1971 Indo-Pak war veteran for “taking a dishonest stand” and opposing grant of benefits to him, saying his Parakram Padak (earlier … Continue reading

Posted in Plot in India |

Benami definition to go stricter, may include only wife, unmarried daughter

NEW DELHI: The government proposes to make the rules regarding benami property ownership much more stringent than they are currently. As part of efforts to prevent black money being tucked away into convenient domestic hidey holes, it could sharply prune … Continue reading

Posted in Property news |